Mitchell was raised in both rural and urban areas of Southern Nevada in a pastor's family of six. After high school, Mitchell moved to Santa Clarita, California to attend The Master's College where he received his B.A. in theology and apologetics in order to pursue his calling in ministry. His wife, Christina was raised in the rural community of Enterprise, Utah in a deacon's home of four. They married in 2011 and moved to Overton in the fall of 2012 to lead the Youth Ministry of Lake Mead Baptist Church under the leadership of Scott Adams. On January 1st 2017, they welcomed their first child Charlie into the world. In August of 2019 Mitchell became the Pastor of Lake Mead Baptist Church.